๐Ÿ”’

SEALED

All accusation sheets must be submitted before this is opened. Host opens after the final accusation round.

๐Ÿ”“ Solution Reveal

The Killer Is
REENA MEHROTRA
Junior Partner ยท 44 ยท Desai & Associates
"I'll come to your office. We can talk."

The Crime

Vikram Desai had spent the day assembling a case against his most trusted junior partner. Reena had been ghostwriting legal arguments for Sharma & Partners โ€” the opposing counsel in a live case โ€” and had separately forged his signature to divert โ‚น18 lakh from a client settlement into an account she controlled. He called her at 7:45 PM and again at 8:28 PM. The second call was the final summons.

During the confrontation in Room 1401, Reena picked up the glass paperweight from Vikram's desk and struck him once from behind. She repositioned the body near the bookshelf, scattered the desk papers to simulate a fall, removed the paperweight, and walked out at 9:18 PM โ€” telling the security guard she was "just finishing up."

She told police she had left at 8:00 PM. Her keycard, the CCTV, and her own taxi app proved otherwise.

Scoring

CategoryMax Points
Correct killer identified50
Correct motive stated (forgery + Bar Council violation)25
Correct method (blunt instrument, staged fall)15
Keycard/CCTV timeline gap cited as evidence15
Taxi booking discrepancy identified (E16)10
Financial forgery chain reconstructed (E08 โ†’ E14 โ†’ E15)15
Each red herring correctly identified and cleared10 each (max 30)
TOTAL160
๐Ÿ“– Case Debrief
Read after scoring is complete. Discuss with the group.
What Each Red Herring Was Designed to Do
๐ŸŽญ Siddharth Kapoor โ€” the angry client
Professional dispute over a failing โ‚น40cr case + physical presence in the building that evening. Most groups spend Round 1 on Siddharth. His CCTV exit at 8:20 PM is independently confirmed โ€” he was gone 10 minutes before the murder window opened.
๐ŸŽญ Arjun Nair โ€” the HR grudge
A formal HR warning six weeks prior suggests simmering resentment. But his keycard log places him on the 14th floor until 8:46 PM โ€” after which the murder window had not yet opened โ€” and CCTV confirms his lobby departure.
๐ŸŽญ Priya Desai โ€” the inheritance motive
A daughter with a โ‚น2.2cr financial stake in her father's death is the most instinctive accusation. Her Koregaon Park restaurant alibi is confirmed by four independent witnesses across three hours โ€” and she never appeared on the 14th floor keycard log.
The Hardest Connection in This Case
The four-source corroboration chain. Reena's keycard (E02) shows her on the 14th floor from 19:52. Her police statement (E11) claims she left at 20:00. Lata's statement (E13) places her office light on at 20:50. Her taxi booking (E16) shows the first ride request at 21:22 from ICC Tower. Each data point comes from a different independent system โ€” building access control, police interview, eyewitness, and a private app. Most groups find one or two. The AHA moment is when all four are placed side by side on the timeline.
What Most Groups Miss
The desk note (E09). Most groups identify Reena through the access log and her contradicted statement. Few decode Vikram's cryptic working note โ€” "RM-SP", "HDFC 4421", "BC complaint" โ€” before the financial evidence arrives in Pack B. Groups that decode E09 early have a fundamentally different experience: they understand the motive before they close the timeline, which changes how the accusation lands emotionally. They're not just catching a liar โ€” they're catching someone who knew they were about to be destroyed.
Discussion Questions
  • How long did it take to narrow down who was physically present during the murder window?
  • The staged fall โ€” did anyone suggest it before finding the forensic evidence, or did the evidence lead you there?
  • Did you find the forgery before or after you identified Reena as the suspect?
  • Who did you suspect at the end of Round 1? What changed in Round 3?
โšฟ CASE CLOSED  ยท  THE LAST CLAUSE  ยท  CaseBoard: The Indian Detective Files
Generate Detective Certificates
CASE CLOSED โ€” AWARD CERTIFICATES TO YOUR TEAM