EVIDENCE REF: E11 ยท CASE CB-03 ยท PACK B
WITNESS STATEMENT โ€” REENA MEHROTRA
Junior Partner, Desai & Associates โ€” ICC Trade Tower, Pune
Pune Police โ€” Shivajinagar Station ยท Case No. PPD-2025-0488 Recorded: 7 March 2025, 10:30 AM ยท Recording Officer: PI Sunil Deshpande
Witness Details
FieldDetails
Full NameReena Suresh Mehrotra
Age44 years
OccupationJunior Partner, Desai & Associates
AddressFlat 7B, Samridhi Towers, Baner Road, Pune 411 045
Relationship to deceasedProfessional โ€” partner at same law firm
Statement โ€” As Recorded
"I have been a partner at Desai & Associates for four years. Mr. Vikram Desai was the senior partner โ€” he founded the firm. I joined as an associate and was made junior partner about two years ago.

On the 6th of March, I was working late on a brief โ€” a court filing due on the 10th. I was in my office, Room 1402. Vikram called me at some point in the evening โ€” I think it was around 7:45 โ€” just to check something about the filing. A brief call. I told him I would sort it and we hung up. He called again later โ€” maybe 8:30 or so โ€” but it was very short, I think I may have already been leaving. I did not speak much.

I finished my work at approximately 8 o'clock. I packed up, took the lift down, and left the building. I cannot say exactly โ€” maybe 8, maybe a bit before. I took a taxi home. I don't remember seeing anyone in particular when I left.

I heard about Vikram's death the next morning when Arjun called me. I was shocked. He was a very private man, very careful. I cannot imagine who would have wanted to harm him."
Contradictions & Investigator Notes โ€” PI Deshpande
CONTRADICTION 1 โ€” Departure Time: Reena states she left at "approximately 8 o'clock" or "maybe a bit before." ICC Tower keycard log (E02) records her badge entry at 19:52 and no exit from the 14th floor until 21:18 โ€” over one hour and eighteen minutes after her stated departure. CCTV confirms her in the lobby at 21:18:04 (E03).
CONTRADICTION 2 โ€” Second Call: Reena describes the 20:28 call from Vikram as brief and suggests she "may have already been leaving." Phone records (E05) confirm the call was connected and lasted 38 seconds at 20:28 โ€” well inside the building based on the keycard record.
CONTRADICTION 3 โ€” No Taxi Record: Reena states she "took a taxi home" after leaving at approximately 20:00. Ride-hailing app records (available in Pack C โ€” E16) show her first cab booking of the evening was at 21:22, from ICC Trade Tower. No booking exists for any earlier departure.
Reena does not mention being present during the murder window. She does not acknowledge the second phone call took place inside the building. She offers no explanation for the 21:18 keycard exit or the 21:22 taxi booking. Statement is inconsistent with three independent physical records.
Reena Suresh Mehrotra
Witness โ€” Signature
PI Sunil Deshpande โ€” PPD/SNJR/0671
Recording Officer
Date: 7 March 2025
Time: 11:14 AM
โ† Back to Pack B